I wrote back a month or two ago that I wanted some good jeans. I tried the J. Crew Vintage slim but those aren’t slim at all. At least with the waists they’re stocking.
Back then, the 484 slim was a new arrival. Back then, I couldn’t fit my legs into them, but now for some strange reason (malnourishment and toning exercises), I can glide into them. They’re tight at the calves, but not skin-tight everywhere else. I think it’s a real nice silhouette of my now meager and frail legs.
On me, they’re just “slimmer than what people are used to seeing on me” jeans. I don’t think they count as skinny yet, since I still have the excess fabric at the thighs. They’re not attached to me like leggings, nor are my jewels turning blue from anything other than the indigo dye.
There’s a good reason why good jeans cost more. I have a pair of STF 501’s, but the legs fit around me like parachute pants. I tried the GAP 1969 denim, but one dreadful rainy day, the colors were erased! It could happen to my 484s, but I’m prepared for the weather next time, I hope.
The J Crew 484 and the vintage slim are pretty light denim, so it would suit well into spring. I chose indigo over black because I find black harder to pair stuff with. And it was that white-speckled material I find to be cheap and not worth the price.

Right now, it’s almost black. This is as close as I’m coming to capturing the color. My photography skills are floating away.
I can’t cuff a lot, but I don’t like cuffing anyways. If I feel like it, it will give me a little cuff and that satisfies me just fine. If these hit $50 during Christmas, I’m stocking up. I highly doubt it, but you never know. If these last 6 months, it’ll be an investment worth the $91. If I wear them constantly for a month, it’ll have redeemed itself in value.
Edit:
About the fit: it’s pretty narrow. When I first picked it up in store, I first thought they were made for women as it looked smaller than anything in their store. Nonetheless, it sits at my waist pretty comfortably. I can breath fine but I got one 1 size bigger than normal. The thighs are not as tight as the knee and below. For me, I need to put on socks before pants.
Remember that you need a kind of physique to fit into slim fit jeans, especially these. If you want a tapered jean but have fuller legs, try their vintage slim fit. Same basic design, except the 484 is slimmer. Same quality denim with more room. I liked the dill, but due to the cut, I would need a size 28 or so, which they don’t make.
Best suggestion: try them on in store. I didn’t think I could fit but it worked out well. Not all stores carry all 484 slim or vintage slim jeans (bigger, popular stores will, but the more localized might not).
Last word: After a day of wear, they’re settling at the hips. Taper not too extreme, skinniness not too skinny. Denim is light, but it is quite soft and comfortable.
Updates: If only they made a size 28×30 or 29×30. The waist has always been too loose for me. I wouldn’t pay full price again, but if it’s discounted for $50, it’s a pretty good deal. Indigo on everything: my bag, my shirts, my jackets, and even my arms and thighs.
Still love the taper, but the butt part is pretty loose.